Fixed Price vs Cost Plus Contracts Which Suits Your Build

Building Tips/Advice

Fixed Price vs Cost Plus Contracts: Which Suits Your Build?

A fixed price contract sets one price before work starts, and you pay it in agreed stages. A cost plus contract charges what the job actually costs, plus an agreed margin, invoiced as the work happens with receipts attached.

Fixed price suits a job whose plans and selections are settled. Cost plus suits a job with more unknowns, such as an older house where nobody can see inside the walls until they come down. Under either contract, a change you ask for is still yours to pay.

We offer both at Extrabuild, on a standard Master Builders Association contract, so this is a conversation we have with clients before they sign. Here is how each one works, where a surprise ends up, and what NSW law requires whichever you choose.

How each contract sets the price and bills you

Payment timelines for fixed price and cost plus contracts Fixed price: one price agreed at signing, a deposit of no more than 10 percent, then fixed payments as each stage of work is completed. Cost plus: an estimate given before signing, a deposit of no more than 10 percent, then invoices as costs are incurred, each with receipts and the margin added. Fixed price (lump sum) One price, agreed before work starts DepositStageStageStageHandover Set amounts, each due when a stage is done Cost plus (do and charge) An estimate first, then the real cost as it comes DepositThen invoices with receipts, as costs come in cost margin
The two payment types NSW allows: stage payments of a set amount or percentage, or payments as costs are incurred with a margin. A contract can also mix them. The estimate before signing is how we work. Bar heights are illustrative, not to scale. Source: NSW Government, Contracts for residential building work (updated 29 April 2026).

Under a fixed price contract, the payment schedule lists set amounts, each due when a stage of work described in the contract is complete. Under cost plus, you pay as work is done and costs come in, and NSW rules say each of those claims must be backed by invoices, receipts or other documents.

At Extrabuild, the margin covers overheads and profit.

Either way, the deposit cannot be more than 10% of the contract price.

Where does a surprise land?

The real difference shows up when something changes partway through. Pick an event and switch between the two contracts to see who pays and how it reaches you.

An example extension, $300,000 contractIllustrative figures

The table below gives the same answers without the interactive.

During the buildFixed priceCost plus
Rotten floor bearers found once the old floor comes upA written variation, signed by both of you, with the price change worked out. You pay it.Charged at cost plus the margin on the next invoice, with receipts.
You decide to upgrade the bathroom tilesA written variation. You pay it.Charged at cost plus the margin.
You pick an oven dearer than the allowanceThe oven was a prime cost item: an allowance, not a final price. Your contract sets how the gap is charged.Charged at what it costs, plus the margin.
The builder orders the wrong size windowThe builder’s fault, so you don’t pay to fix it.The builder’s fault, so you don’t pay to fix it.
Timber prices rise during the buildUsually the builder carries it, unless the contract says the price can change. That warning must be on the first page.You pay the higher cost, plus the margin.
Bricks come in under the estimateThe price stays the same.You pay less.
Variation and builder’s-fault rules: NSW Government, Contracts for residential building work. Each contract’s wording decides the detail, so read the variation, prime cost and price-change clauses before you sign.

So the choice is mostly about who carries the risk of prices and quantities moving. With a fixed price, the builder usually carries it and allows for that risk in the price. With cost plus, you carry it, and in return you see every cost and keep any saving.

What NSW law requires either way

For residential work worth more than $20,000, these steps apply to both contract types.

  1. A written contract that names the licence holder and shows the contract price prominently on the first page. If the price could change or isn’t known, the contract must say so and explain why.
  2. Five clear business days to cool off after you’re given a copy of the contract.
  3. A Home Building Compensation certificate from the builder. Until you have it, the builder can’t ask for a deposit or any other payment.
  4. A deposit of no more than 10% of the contract price.
  5. A copy of the signed contract within five business days of signing.
  6. Every variation in writing, signed by both of you, with the price change worked out rather than just a dollar figure.
Source: NSW Government, Contracts for residential building work (updated 29 April 2026). For jobs between $5,000 and $20,000, a shorter small jobs contract applies.

Which one suits your job

Your projectOften suitsWhy
A new home with plans, specifications and selections settledFixed priceLittle is unknown, so a firm price is easy to give and easy to hold.
A renovation or extension to an older houseCost plusWhat’s inside the walls and under the floor shows up only once work starts. A fixed price has to allow for that, or meet it with variations.
Your lender wants one firm figureFixed priceLenders often want a firm contract price, and some have rules on progress payments. Check with yours.
You want to start before every selection is madeCost plusCosts are charged as they’re known, without a run of prime cost adjustments.
A guide only. The right contract depends on your plans, your finance and how much certainty you need, so talk it through with us before you choose.

How we handle each at Extrabuild

  • We use a standard Master Builders Association contract, and you choose a lump sum (fixed price) or cost plus contract.
  • Before you sign, we take you through a detailed proposal with either a detailed fixed price or a detailed cost plus price.
  • On cost plus jobs, every invoice comes with a detailed budget report listing all related expenses, direct and indirect, to back up each progress payment.
  • After signing, we arrange your Home Building Compensation cover and give you the certificate before we ask for the 10% deposit or any other payment.
  • You get an identical signed copy of the contract, with drawings and specifications, within five business days.

There’s a sample of our lump sum contract and a full list of what a cost plus job can include on our FAQ page, and every step from first meeting to handover on our building process page.

Questions

Is cost plus more expensive than fixed price?

Not by design. A fixed price usually includes an allowance for the risk of things changing. Cost plus doesn’t need that allowance, but you carry any overrun. Which one ends up cheaper depends on how much changes during the build.

Can a fixed price go up?

Yes. It goes up through variations you agree to in writing, through prime cost items, and through a price-change clause if the contract has one. A builder’s own mistake isn’t a reason for you to pay more.

What is a prime cost item?

Something you haven’t chosen yet when you sign, such as a stove or special fittings. The contract lists it with an allowance that covers the builder’s expected cost. Choosing products before you sign keeps those allowances accurate.

Does cost plus mean I can’t budget?

No. We give you an estimate of the total cost before you sign, and the contract must warn you on its first page that the final price isn’t fixed. NSW rules also require each claim to be backed by documents, and on our cost plus jobs the budget report with each invoice shows where you stand against the estimate.

Not sure which contract fits your job? Paul can take you through both before you sign. Call 0407 100 424 or get in touch.

How we worked this out. NSW rules are from the NSW Government page Contracts for residential building work, last updated 29 April 2026. The $300,000 example and the event costs in the interactive are illustrative, not Extrabuild prices, and so is the margin: your contract states the real one. Extrabuild’s process is from our FAQ and building process pages.

What Our Newcastle Clients Say

We’re proud to have completed granny flats and building projects across Newcastle and Lake Macquarie, delivering quality workmanship and exceptional communication.

The Journey to Loving Where You Live Starts Here